KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (14...Qc7), delta2 = -0.12 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (15...Bxh2+), delta = 0.35 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (16...Bd6, nearly forced move), delta = 0.76 KRAMNIK 1110 PART MATCH (17...Be7), delta2 = -0.03 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (18...0-0), delta = 0.19 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (19...Qxe7), delta = almost 5.0. Nothing to see here. KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (20...Rfd8), delta2 = -0.11 (note -0.17 at 17 ply) KRAMNIK 0100 PART MATCH (21...c5), delta2 = -0.13 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (22...Ne4), delta2 = -0.31 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (23...Bxe4), delta = 5.02+ (forced move) KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (24...Bd3), delta2 = -0.08 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (25...Rac8), delta = 0.24 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (26...Rb8), delta = 0.06 (significant) KRAMNIK 1100 PART MATCH (27...Be4), delta2 = -0.03 KRAMNIK 0010 PART MATCH (28...Rb7), delta2 = -0.08 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (29...Bg6), delta = 0.06 KRAMNIK 0011 MATCH (30...h6), delta = 0.02 KRAMNIK 000T PART MATCH (31...Kh7), delta = 0.00. KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (32...Be4), delta = 0.37 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (33...Bd5), delta = 0.44 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (34...Rdb8), delta2 = -0.43. KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (35,,,f5, forced), delta = 0.84 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (36...Qh4, semi-forced), delta = 0.48 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (37...Qg3), delta2 = -0.33 KRAMNIK 1011 MATCH (38...Rf7), delta = 0.05 (but non-match at 16 ply) KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (39...Qg6), delta2 <= -0.14. KRAMNIK 0011 MATCH (40...Qg3), delta = 0.05 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (41...Rfb7), delta = -0.57 (from first 15/15 run) KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (42...Qg5), delta = 0.21 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (43...Qf6), delta2 = -0.23 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (44...Rd7), delta = 0.05 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (45...Rbd8), delta2 = -0.13 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (46...Kg8), delta2 = -0.37 (and falling) KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (47...Bxc4), delta2 = -0.07 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (48...f4), delta = 0.47 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (49...fxe3), delta2 = -0.13 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (50...Rxd4), delta = 0.17 (but obvious followup move?) KRAMNIK 000T PART MATCH TIE (51...Qh4), delta = 0.00 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (52...Qxd4), delta = 0.05 KRAMNIK 1111 FULL MATCH (53...Kh7), delta = 0.39 (only!) 13 non-matches 18 full matches 9 partial matches -- 27 / 40 with some degree of matching, = 67.5% Matches at: 12 ply: 21 / 40 13 ply: 21 / 40 14 ply: 23 / 40 57.5% 15 ply: 21.5 / 40. Fair-weighted Hamming metric: 18x15 + 7 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 12 + 4 + 13 + 12 + 4 / 600 = 331/600 = 55.2% Danailov claimed 30 matches. On the non-matches: KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (47...Bxc4), delta2 = -0.07 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (24...Bd3), delta2 = -0.08 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (20...Rfd8), delta2 = -0.11 (note -0.17 at 17 ply) KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (14...Qc7), delta2 = -0.12 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (45...Rbd8), delta2 = -0.13 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (49...fxe3), delta2 = -0.13 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (39...Qg6), delta2 <= -0.14. KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (43...Qf6), delta2 = -0.23 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (22...Ne4), delta2 = -0.31 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (37...Qg3), delta2 = -0.33 KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (46...Kg8), delta2 = -0.37 (and falling) KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (34...Rdb8), delta2 = -0.43. KRAMNIK 0000 NON-MATCH (41...Rfb7), delta = -0.57 (from first 15/15 run) It is within experimental error for some 3 of the 7 closest non-matches to have been viewed as a match in their run(s). It is not within error for there to be 30 matches at any ply depth; even to get 7 more matches at 14 ply requires basically all 7 numbers around 1 Fritz std. dev. to go their way, less than a 1-in-2^7 < 1% chance.