Paper Review Form

Paper Title:

Student's Name:

     
Q1: Contributions (What are the major issues addressed in the paper? Do you consider them important? Comment on the novelty, creativity, and technical depth of the paper.)

     
Q2: Briefly summarize the main ideas/the approach to the solution.

     
Q3: What are the paper's strengths? Be brief.

     
Q4: What are the paper's weaknesses? Be brief.

     
Q5: Comment on the paper's evaluation methodology.

     
Q6: Are there any issues/directions this work left open? List a few possible extensions of this work.

     
Q7: Any other comments/questions.